Step three in hopefully getting closer to a guild heraldry cloak we like.

To maybe get better feedback this time I just took 5 different ones that i kind of like, and then we can maybe find one that most like and just tweak it a little to get closer to settling on one.

But before that, first I want to make a case against black; black is a popular color, sure, and I would normally be fine with picking it, even if half the rest of the guilds will have the same color; but for some reason, black looks HORRIBLE in warhammer.



It is totally washed out, it looks like a really bad grey; and its unfortunately not just black, it seems all dark colors are like this; dark blue and red included. Because of that, I say we go for a lighter color.

So, because the dark colors are horrible, I took a few variations of lighter color cloaks, and I also took a variation of the circle snake emblem as pilois requested it hehe:

Option1:


Option2:


Option3:


Option4:


Option5:


The full gallery of all of them is here also: http://war.enmity.mmoguildsites.net/gallery_categories/3127

Personally I am really warming up to the idea of an orange cloak..

Nobody has an orange cloak for their guild I've seen, and it sticks out very nicely when you are in a crowd, amid all the black and blue cloaks most people seem to wear. You can dye your cloak orange at a vendor and it seems to be a nice tint also, not washed out as much as other colors.

I like options 3 and 5, but prefer the non-circle snake emblem; maybe like Option 5 with a non-circle snake hehe

Option 2 or option 4 without the circle snake looks pretty cool

I really like option 1.

edit: option 3 is also good.

I like options 1-3 the best.

I think 2 and 3 will be the best to match to dye colors, though I may be wrong. Unfortunately I'm super busy this week as well as the last few weeks and can't verify that in game

I like option 2.

Lets just pick one!

Agree! Executive decision time

I like option 2. option 1 is okay but its missing something.

Well going by what people generally seem to like, option 2 is the clear winner.

Option 2 also

screw your ork clan icons. Option 1 with Option 2 paint scheme, or just Option 1.

Inclined to option 2 myself.

It's simple and dignified and the color scheme pleases my eyes overall.

Well we're in no rush; we don't get guild cloaks til guild level 20 so still at least a week away..

I'll post a few more variations similar to 2 and 3 this week

Uh we have guild cloaks already. Its rank 15.

pattern @ 15, the "logo" is @ 20

My initial pick, based on aesthetics and not overthinking it is:

Choice1 = Option #1
Choice2 = Option #2

I'd be fine with either of them really.

I wouldn't mind option 1 I guess, but something is off with it. maybe the colors? dunno. Jars me somehow.